Trainer on 3 breeds he’d ‘never own’ after years of working with dogs

A dog behaviour expert has said there are three breeds he’d never own – despite a lengthy career working with an eclectic selection of dogs.

For countless people, the prospect of getting a dog is appealing. They’re not just loyal and excellent companions, but also bring humour into our lives and give us the perfect excuse for getting out of the house for daily walks and fresh air.

But choosing to get a pet isn’t a decision to be made lightly; dogs require significant time and care throughout their whole lives – a fact that shouldn’t be ignored in the rush to welcome a new four-legged family member.

Choosing the right breed is crucial and, with this in mind, dog behaviour expert Will Atherton shared the specific breeds he would avoid, despite his extensive expertise and knowledge in handling various dogs.

In an Instagram video, Atherton, who boasts hundreds of thousands of followers on the popular social media platform, began: “These are the three breeds that I want but I’ll never have, even as a canine behaviourist that has the skill and experience to be able to manage pretty much any dog.”

1. Turkish Kangal

Originating from Sivas province in Turkey, the Turkish Kangal is a formidable and sturdy breed initially bred to protect livestock against predators like wolves, bears, and jackals.

Renowned for their unparalleled loyalty, keen intelligence, and protective instincts, the Kangal has been trusted for guarding sheep and goats for generations.

Will said: “Number one, is the Turkish Kangal and they’ve been on my shortlist for probably a decade. I truly think they’re one of the most beautiful dogs on the planet. However, they are a serious dog and they don’t mix well with a normal family life.”

2. Caucasian shepherd

Famed for their imposing size and power as protectors of livestock, the Caucasian shepherd dog, also referred to as the Caucasian Ovcharka, originates from the Caucasus Mountains straddling Europe and Asia. Historically, this breed has defended sheep, warding off predators such as wolves, bears, and jackals. They’re recognised for their courage, loyalty, and protective instincts.

Following discussion on the Turkish Kangal, Will provided additional observations regarding Caucasian shepherds.

He said: “The same can be said for the Caucasian Shepherd – everything about the Kangal but just times two; insanely serious and the challenge of being able to raise a really good one is something that whispers at the back of my mind every now and again.

“However I take my own advice and understand that it would just be a terrible choice for my lifestyle.”

3. English mastiff

The English Mastiff, typically referred to as the “mastiff,” is a large breed, valued for its gentle temperament and loyalty. As one of the world’s most ancient and heaviest breeds, it was initially bred in England to function as a guard dog, a companion in warfare, and a hunting partner.

They’re frequently celebrated as the ultimate “gentle giants,” owing to their tranquil temperament and profound devotion to their human families.

Despite their appealing characteristics, Will remains reluctant about welcoming another Mastiff into his life. The breed’s lifespan is usually quite brief, ranging from 6 to 10 years – a result of their massive size.

Sadly, they are vulnerable to numerous health complications too, including joint problems, heart conditions and obesity.

Will voiced his worries and added: “Last of all is a dog that I have already had, which is the English mastiff and I would be desperate to have another one because they are an amazing pick for my family. But just how prone they are to serious health issues is just something that I’m not sure I can take the risk with again.”

The post resonated with followers, encouraging them to share their own experiences. A fellow dog lover said: “We have a Turkish Kangal, we know what you mean, but we have been soooo lucky with her. We love them as a breed and would love to keep adopting more.”

Another said: “I would love to have a Rottweiler again, but don’t think I have what it takes anymore”, followed by a crying laughing emoji. Others were eager to share their favourite dog breeds.

Before committing to getting a dog, research is essential. Training is often necessary, and not every breed is suitable for first-time owners. For those genuinely keen to welcoming a dog into their household, it’s worth looking into the benefits of rescuing from a charity or local shelter instead of buying from a breeder.